Document Type : Systematic review
Department of Cardiology, Quaem Hospital, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Introduction: Ischemic heart disease is caused mainly by obstruction of coronary arteries. The ischemic assessment through echocardiography is dependent on wall motion abnormality detection during systole. In patients with ischemic heart disease the diastolic function is impaired before systolic function and measurement of regional diastolic dysfunction if possible will be most sensitive for assessment of obstructed coronary artery region. This study was designed to determine whether regional left ventricular delayed relaxation diagnosis could be detected with strain imaging derived from two-dimensional speckle-tracking echocardiography in patients with coronary artery disease.
Methods: All the articles reviewed were obtained using MEDLINE & ScienceDirect (up to October 2014). All data extracted by speckle tracking echocardiography. The index which is used is strain imaging diastolic index which is calculated as: (A-B) A×100 . A is the amount of strain at the time Aortic value closure and B is the amount of strain in first one-third point of diastolic duration.
Result: Four articles were reviewed. Three articles assessed patients with echocardiography at rest and one with stress echocardiography. All articles showed the coronary artery tracking with significant stenosis is possible by regional deformation analysis through two-dimensional strain.
Discussion: The usage of strain images obtained through two-dimensional speckle tracking has been validated for the quantitation assessment of regional dysfunction in ischemic heart disease. Regional LV delayed relaxation diagnosis with strain imaging is a reliable method after treadmill stress test.
Conclusion: Strain imaging is reasonable for evaluation of ischemia as a low cost noninvasive test with high accuracy.
Ischemic heart disease (IHD) is caused mainly by obstruction of coronary arteries due to atheromatous plaque and it’s main symptom is chest discomfort. It usually become worse by activities and it is related to an impairment in myocardial function. The patient usually feels the pain in retrosternal region, but it commonly radiates and is felt down the ulnar surface of the left arm ,right arm and the outer surfaces of both arms. This pain usually grows step by step and maximizes in a few minutes and is relieved soon by resting or the use of short-acting nitroglycerin.
49% of men and 32% of women are suffering from symptomatic coronary artery diseases (CAD) after the age of forty (1).
The increase of annual income is accompanied with the population increase in cities and the rate of obesity in Middle East (including in Iran), the cardiovascular disease mortality is increasing quickly and the CAD is the main cause of death (25-45%) in this region.
A high fiber and low fat diet is being transfered to western diets. And in recent decades daily fat consumption has increased in these countries (2).
CAD is the main cause of mortality throughout the world and thus it’s accurate assessment is vital.
Diagnostic procedures for this disease are invasive and noninvasive tests. Among noninvasive tests we can name stress tests which gives useful information about diagnosis confirmation, exercise capacity and tolerance, prognosis and also the ischemic severity (1).
Echocardiographic images are so valuable for the assessment of cardiac function because it is dynamic (3). The myocardial ischemic assessment through echocardiography is dependent on the wall motion abnormality detection and wall thickness reduction during systole. Traditionally this assessment is done visually and therefore is subjective (4).
Echocardiographic CAD diagnosis is usually dependent on stress tests, because the systolic impairment is not always visible at rest unless if infarcted myocardium exists. Stress echocardiography is the started method for coronary artery disease diagnosis (5).
On the other hand in patients with IHD the diastolic function is impaired before systolic function and the measurement of regional diastolic dysfunction if possible will be most sensitive for assessment of obstructed coronary artery region(6).
Visual analysis of wall motion abnormality is not capable to assess diastolic dysfunction accurately (7,8). Therefore new automated techniques has been created for advance analysis of cardiac mechanics. Due to difference in interpretations in last decades two such technique has been demonstrated in echocardiographic research fields. 1) The measurement of tissue velocity base on Doppler 2) speckle tracking base on displacement measurement (3). It has been reported that the modern echocardiographic technology in combination with standardized image processing and uniform reading criteria has resulted to more coordination in echocardiographic interpretation in compared to previous reports (9). Speckle tracking echocardiography (STE) is based on tracking of frame myocardial speckles in grayscale images. Speckles are very small structure in images which are visible after noise filtering. STE can be used for myocardial velocity and strain measurement (10). This technique is not limited to angle like TDI. And is obtained from 50-80 frame rate per second images. Velocity vector imaging is base on the similar principle and deformation measurements has been validated by vector velocity imaging against sonomicrometry (11).
The index which is used in many studies to analysis strain images is strain imaging diastolic index (SIDI) which is calculated as follows:
In this equation A stands for the amount of strain at the time Aortic value closure and B stands for the amount of strain in first one-third paint of diastolic duration (12).
The search was carried out with these keywords: diastolic dysfunction AND strain imaging AND ischemic heart disease (Figure 1). All the articles reviewed here were obtained using MEDLINE & SScienceDirect (up to October 2014), all were controlled trials with consensus on patients with CAD confirmed by selective coronary angiography. The studies had focused on those with suspicious CAD cases without any significant valvular disease, conduction abnormalities, pacemaker, ongoing arrhythmia, congenital heart disease, previous cardiac surgery, emergency angiograms, hemodynamic instability. The collected data have been summarized in Table 1.
In a research done by Liang et all. In 2006 the objective was to analyse the impact of stenosis of more than 70% of coronary arteries on deformation of the regional diastolic function during rest by the usage of strain echocardiography. In this research the patients underwent echocardiography in 24h after the angiography and strain and strain rate in systole and diastole were measured. 39 patients out of 61 participants had coronary artery stenosis more than 70% and 15 subjects had normal coronary arteries. Systolic and diastolic strain rate reduced significantly in ischemic regions in comparision to the normal regions. This research concluded that the coronary artery tracking whit significant stenosis is possible by regional deformation analysis through 2D strain at rest. The altered diastolic deformation revealed the ischemic territories with higher specificity. Control and ischemic subjects were matched for invasive left ventricular and aortic pressures and noninvasive hemodynamic details. The control subjects were not patients with low possibility of cardiovascular disease and this might affect on sensitivity of 2 dimentional speckle tracking echocardiography parameters (8).
In another research by Kimura et all. Which was carried out in 2011 the goal was to determine coronary artery stenosis in clinical patients by SI-DI at rest. 85 patients with probable CAD, EF˃50 which had undergone coronary angiography and echocardiography were studied retrospectively. They observed that the SI-DI decreases significantly in regions with sever stenosis (more than 75%) but the peak strain was stable. This research proved that SI-DI is a new strategy for sever coronary stenosis diagnosis. They showed that even a mild stenosis may cause ischemic changes in diastolic dysfunction. Coronary branch stenosis and also anatomic variations were ignored in this study which may impact the myocardial function (5).
A research was done by Ishii et all in 2009 in order to study LV relaxation delay after ischemia by 2D strain echocardiography images in patients with stable angina. The changes in regional LV strain curve in the first one-third of diastolic duration was measured in 162 patients with stable angina 5 and 10 minutes after the exercise test. SI-DI and SI-DI ratio (SI-DI before and after the test) was used in order to demonstrate regional LV delayed relaxation. 117 patients had significant coronary artery stenosis. The average SI-DI decrease in 191 patients with significant stenosis in coronary perfusion territory while it did not change in 280 patients with non significant stenosis. Regional delayed relaxation was observed in 85% of subjects with significant stenosis in coronary perfusion territory 10 minutes after the exercise. They concluded that determining regional LV delayed relaxation after the treadmill test by strain imaging is a sensitive and reliable method for CAD diagnosis. It has recently been reported that regional tardorelaxation has been observed after the treadmill stress test in patients with stable exertional angina and CAD and even remained an hour after the exercise while systolic function had completely become normal (7).
In another study that Ishii et al performed in 2009 their objective was to assess regional LV function in systole and diastole after PCI by strain imaging. Peak transverse strain and strain in first one-third of diastolic duration (SI-DI) was studied in 30 CAD patients. The result of the strain data in the involved segments was compared with values obtained from normal segments. It was observed that coronary artery stenosis significantly decreases systolic strain in proximal and distal segments and systolic disorders approached the normal values just after reperfusion. Even so proximal and distal SI-DI values decreased 35 minute after the reperfusion and was still lower in distal segments 24h after the reperfusion. This study shows that diastolic stunning remain despite the complete recovery of systolic function after reperfusion. This study was done with a small population of patients which may reduce the power of statistical inference and it remained undetermined that how long the regional diastolic dysfunction persists after reperfusion (13).
Strain clinical application in CAD
Regional diastolic function assessment like systolic function disturbance is an old concept in CAD. But nowadays it is become possible through TDI and strain imaging (14).There are increasing evidences that ischemia causes regional diastolic mechanical dysfunction and is diagnostic through new echocardiographic technique and these changed patterns can inhance the diagnosis of CAD by echocardiography (15). The usage of strain images obtained through 2D speckle tracking (2DST) has recently been validated for the quantitation assessment of regional dysfunction in IHD (9,16,17). During ischemia the diastolic regional function is disturbed faster than systolic regional function (13). Delay in diastolic relaxation caused by ischemia has been demonstrated regionally in the territory of the perfusion of involved vessel in animal and clinical models (6,8,18-21). Studies has suggested that it is possible to reveal myocardial ischemia by detecting regional motion abnormality in diastole or tardorelaxation through 2DST. The regional delayed relaxation site is coordinated with the territory of the vessel which causes angina (13).
STE in stress echocardiography
Most of the information released about the diastolic mechanic in CAD are concentrated on dysfunction during rest. An important diastolic mechanic role is for CAD diagnosis can be in stress echocardiography (15). There have always been discussions about the strain validity obtained through speckle tracking in stress echocardiography due to lower frame rates compare to the obtained strain by TDI. However the obtained strain from speckle tracking has recently been approved in a study on stress echocardiography with Dobutamine. In this research the correlation among sonomicrometry and strain obtained from speckle was the highest for longitudinal strain and lowest for radial strain (22).
Diastole as a memory
Diastolic stunning assessment may be a new ischemic diagnostic approach (23). Dongdong et all. 2013 conducted an experiment on lab animals, proved that the regional diastolic dysfunction persistency is longer compare to regional systolic dysfunction after prolonged ischemia witch suggests that recent myocardial ischemia can be diagnosed via regional diastolic assessment (24). It was shown Azevedo et all study that the persistence of diastolic dysfunction with cardiac MRI lasts 48h after episodic ischemia in injured non-infarcted segments (25). Neizel et all reported that diagnose regional diastolic dysfunction by cardiac MRI lasts even 6 months after the successful reperfusion of acute myocardial infarction (26).
Sensitivity and Specificity
Schuijf et all conducted is studies with a population of 1849 patients and discovered 84% sensitivity and 82% specificity for CAD detection by dobutamine tress echocardiography (27). A recent study evaluated CAD detection with perfusion Dipyridamole echocardiography by a new ultrasound imaging instrument in comparison with perfusion imaging. The accuracy of perfusion echocardiography (66-71%) was not inferior to radionuclide imaging (67-70%) (28). LV diastolic dysfunction is sensitive and is also an early sign of myocardial ischemia and remains longer than systolic dysfunction. Diastolic deformation analysis with the usage of strain echocardiography can improves the accuracy of echocardiography in significant CAD detection (7,13). Wijns and et all reported that diastolic component may have a lower threshold than the systolic component for ischemia detection. Therefore the region which is less damaged may only show diastolic dysfunction (29). In Kimura et all.2011 study, transverse SI-DI at rest showed 79% sensitivity and 73% specificity for sever CAD (5). In Ishii et all’s 2009 study SI-DI ratio had 97% sensitivity and 93% specificity for stenosis detection more than 50%. Regional LV delayed relaxation diagnosis with strain imaging is a sensitive and reliable method after treadmill stress test (7).
The success of this new algorithm depends on the quality of 2D echocardiography images (10). Image quality may change the test accuracy. The presence of other circumstances like HTN and cardiomyopathies may also alter the accuracy of the test. In most studies major vessel territories are appointed with one segment. Diastole is severely affected by heart rate and no study has been done for tachycardia impact on diastolic strain. Moreover, diastolic dysfunction remains in recovery phase for a long time and the heart rate is low in this phase. So worrying about heart rate may not be appropriate (12).
Using strain imaging for assessment of regional diastolic dysfunction has limitations. Although it is a non invasive method and has accebtable sensitivity and specificity. During ischemia the diastolic regional function is disturbed faster than systolic regional function and persists so longer. Thus, strain imaging is reasonable for evaluation of ischemia as a low cost noninvasive test with high accuracy.
We would like to thank Clinical Research Development Center of Ghaem Hospital for their assistant in this manuscript. This study was supported by a grant from the Vice Chancellor for Research of the Mashhad University of Medical Sciences for the research project as a medical student thesis with approval number of 920382.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- Morrow DA, Boden WE. Stahle Ischemic Heart Disease. In: Mann DL, Zipes DP, Libby P, Bonow RO, editors. Braunwald’s Heart Disease A Textbook of Cardiovascular Medicine. Philadelphia: Elsevier; 2015. p. 1182-1244.
- Safi M, Lotfi R, Taher Khani M, et al. Assessment of ECG indices power in detection of culprit lesion in acute ST elevation MI in comparision to angiography. Pajoohande azar. 1392;14:273-269.
- Mor-Avi V, Lang RM, Badano LP, et al. Current and evolving echocardiographic techniques for the quantitative evaluation of cardiac mechanics: ASE/EAE consensus statement on methodology and indications endorsed by the Japanese Society of Echocardiography. Eur J Echocardiogr. 2011;12:167-205.
- Hoffman R, Lethen H, Kleinhans E, et al. [Dobutamine stress echocardiography and perfusion scintigraphy for detection of myocardial ischemia in patients with and without previous myocardial infarct]. Z Kardiol. 1996;85:20-27.
- Kimura K, Takenaka K, Pan X, et al. Prediction of coronary artery stenosis using strain imaging diastolic index at rest in patients with preserved ejection fraction. J Cardiol. 2011;57:311-315.
- Kondo H, Masuyama T, Ishihara K, et al. Digital subtraction high-frame-rate echocardiography in detecting delayed onset of regional left ventricular relaxation in ischemic heart disease. Circulation. 1995;91:304-312.
- Ishii K, Imai M, Suyama T, et al. Exercise-induced post-ischemic left ventricular delayed relaxation or diastolic stunning: is it a reliable marker in detecting coronary artery disease? J Am Coll Cardiol. 2009;53:698-705.
- Liang H-Y, Cauduro S, Pellikka P, et al. Usefulness of two-dimensional speckle strain for evaluation of left ventricular diastolic deformation in patients with coronary artery disease. Am J cardiol. 2006;98:1581-1586.
- Takagi T, Takagi A, Yoshikawa J. Detection of coronary artery disease using delayed strain imaging at 5min after the termination of exercise stress: Head to head comparison with conventional treadmill stress echocardiography. J Cardiol. 2010;55:41-48.
- Hoit BD. Strain and strain rate echocardiography and coronary artery disease. Circ Cardiovasc Imaging. 2011;4:179-190.
- Pirat B, Khoury DS, Hartley CJ, et al. A novel feature-tracking echocardiographic method for the quantitation of regional myocardial function: validation in an animal model of ischemia-reperfusion. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:651-659.
- Ishii K, Kataoka K, Furukawa A, et al. Diagnostic Value of Exercise-Induced Post-Ischemic Left Ventricular Delayed Relaxation or Diastolic Stunning in Patients With Intermediate Coronary Lesions: Comparison With Myocardial Fractional Flow Reserve. Circulation. 2011;124:A14947.
- Ishizu T, Seo Y, Enomoto Y, et al. Experimental validation of left ventricular transmural strain gradient with echocardiographic two-dimensional speckle tracking imaging. Eur J Echocardiogr. 2010:jep221.
- Oh JK, Park S-J, Nagueh SF. Established and novel clinical applications of diastolic function assessment by echocardiography. Circ Cardiovasc Imaging. 2011;4:444-455.
- Abraham TP, Liang H-Y. Stress echocardiography: diastole to the rescue. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2009;53:706-708.
- Fujimoto H, Honma H, Ohno T, et al. Longitudinal Doppler strain measurement for assessment of damaged and/or hibernating myocardium by dobutamine stress echocardiography in patients with old myocardial infarction. J Cardiol. 2010;55:309-316.
- Ishii K, Suyama T, Imai M, et al. Abnormal regional left ventricular systolic and diastolic function in patients with coronary artery disease undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention: clinical significance of post-ischemic diastolic stunning. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2009;54:1589-1597.
- Garcia-Fernandez M, Azevedo J, Moreno M, et al. Regional diastolic function in ischaemic heart disease using pulsed wave Doppler tissue imaging. Eur heart J. 1999;20:496-505.
- Pislaru C, Belohlavek M, Bae RY, et al. Regional asynchrony during acute myocardial ischemia quantified by ultrasound strain rate imaging. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2001;37:1141-1148.
- Abraham TP, Belohlavek M, Thomson HL, et al. Time to onset of regional relaxation: feasibility, variability and utility of a novel index of regional myocardial function by strain rate imaging. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2002;39:1531-1537.
- Wang J, Abraham TP, Korinek J, et al. Delayed onset of subendocardial diastolic thinning at rest identifies hypoperfused myocardium. Circulation. 2005;111:2943-2950.
- Reant P, Labrousse L, Lafitte S, et al. Experimental validation of circumferential, longitudinal, and radial 2-dimensional strain during dobutamine stress echocardiography in ischemic conditions. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2008;51:149-157.
- Achenbach S, Kramer CM, Zoghbi WA, et al. The year in coronary artery disease. JACC Cardiovasc Imaging. 2010;3:1065-1077.
- Chen D, Liao Y, Xu Q, et al. Persistence of systolic and diastolic regional dysfunction after brief episodes of myocardial ischemia evaluated with velocity vector imaging. Int J Cardiol. 2013;167:987-994.
- Azevedo CF, Amado LC, Kraitchman DL, et al. Persistent diastolic dysfunction despite complete systolic functional recovery after reperfused acute myocardial infarction demonstrated by tagged magnetic resonance imaging. Eur Heart J. 2004;25:1419-1427.
- Neizel M, Korosoglou G, Lossnitzer D, et al. Impact of systolic and diastolic deformation indexes assessed by strain-encoded imaging to predict persistent severe myocardial dysfunction in patients after acute myocardial infarction at follow-up. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2010;56:1056-1062.
- Schuijf JD, Shaw LJ, Wijns W, et al. Cardiac imaging in coronary artery disease: differing modalities. Heart. 2005;91:1110-1117.
- Senior R, Monaghan M, Main ML, et al. Detection of coronary artery disease with perfusion stress echocardiography using a novel ultrasound imaging agent: two Phase 3 international trials in comparison with radionuclide perfusion imaging. Eur J Echocardiogr. 2009;10:26-35.
- Wijns W, Serruys PW, Slager CJ, et al. Effect of coronary occlusion during percutaneous transluminal angioplasty in humans on left ventricular chamber stiffness and regional diastolic pressure-radius relations. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1986;7:455-463.